skip to Main Content

Why Marketing Leadership Positions Are So Hard to Fill at Growth-Stage Companies

If you’ve spent months searching for a marketing executive, you’re not alone. Growth-stage companies struggle to fill marketing leadership positions because they’re usually looking for one person to cover strategy, demand generation, brand, and martech, a combination that rarely exists at a price a mid-market budget can support. The result is a search that drags on while competitors keep moving.

Why does this keep happening?

A decade ago, a marketing director needed to understand branding, media buying, and basic digital execution. Today the discipline has split into specialties: demand generation, marketing automation and CRM systems, paid media, brand strategy, content, analytics, and increasingly AI-driven search and personalization.

Write a job description that asks for a boardroom-level strategist who can also build automation workflows and manage a paid media budget, and you’re describing two or three different careers folded into one title. Candidates who genuinely have all of it tend to be excellent at none of it, or they’re priced well above what the role’s budget allows.

What does an open marketing leadership position actually cost?

The visible cost is the search itself. Director, VP, and CMO-level marketing searches are typically run on a retained basis, and retained search firms charge 20% to 30% of the executive’s first-year base salary for these roles, often split into installments starting before a single candidate is interviewed. With marketing director base salaries commonly running $130,000 to $230,000, VP roles $180,000 to $300,000, and CMO packages $225,000 to $500,000+, that translates to recruiter fees of roughly $25,000 to $150,000+ per hire, committed before you know if the search will land the right person.

The less visible cost is what happens if the hire doesn’t work out. Marketing performance is often hard for non-marketing executives to evaluate in the first 100 days, which means a mis-hire can go unaddressed for two full quarters before it’s corrected. Industry estimates put the total cost of a failed senior hire, lost productivity, team disruption, and restarting the search, at three to five times the role’s annual salary.

For a board or PE sponsor tracking growth against a thesis, that’s not just a staffing delay. It shows up in CAC trends, pipeline coverage, and the next quarterly review.

Who is actually running marketing while the search continues?

Usually the CEO, a generalist ops leader, or an existing agency without anyone internally set up to direct them. None of that is a strategy; it’s a placeholder that erodes momentum the longer it runs.

This is the gap a fractional CMO is built to close: senior leadership that starts steering strategy immediately, without the 6-month search or the salary-plus-equity commitment of a full-time executive hire. Fractional isn’t the only alternative to a full-time hire, either. If you’re weighing fractional against interim or deciding whether a full-time search is even the right call, here’s how the four models actually compare.


Stop letting open marketing leadership positions stall your growth.

indigoOne has spent decades building marketing strategy for growth-stage and PE-backed companies, contributing to client outcomes totaling $3.5B+ in enterprise value. If you need senior leadership in place now, not in six months, let’s talk.

Schedule a 20-minute consultation


Key Takeaways

  • Growth-stage marketing leadership roles are hard to fill because companies are typically searching for one person to cover strategy, demand generation, brand, and martech, a combination that rarely exists at a price a mid-market budget can support.
  • Retained search firms charge 20% to 30% of the executive’s first-year base salary, translating to recruiter fees of roughly $25,000 to $150,000+ per hire, often committed before a single candidate is interviewed.
  • A mis-hire can go unaddressed for two full quarters, since marketing performance is often hard for non-marketing executives to evaluate in the first 100 days, and the total cost of a failed senior hire can run three to five times the role’s annual salary.
  • While a search continues, marketing is usually run by the CEO, a generalist ops leader, or an unsupervised agency, none of which is a strategy, just a placeholder that erodes momentum.
  • A fractional CMO closes this gap, providing senior leadership immediately without the 6-month search or the salary-plus-equity commitment of a full-time executive hire.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it typically take to fill a marketing director role?

At growth-stage and mid-market companies, searches for a senior marketing executive commonly run four to six months, longer if the role requires a specific industry background or the budget doesn’t match current market compensation.

How much does it cost to hire a marketing director through a recruiter?

Director, VP, and CMO-level marketing searches are typically handled through retained search, which charges 20% to 30% of the executive’s first-year base salary. With base salaries commonly ranging from $130,000 for a director-level role to $500,000+ for a CMO, that translates to recruiter fees of roughly $25,000 to $150,000 or more per hire.

Why is it hard to find one person who can do it all in marketing?

Modern marketing spans specialties, demand generation, brand strategy, marketing automation, paid media, and analytics, that used to sit under one title but now require different skill sets. Finding a single hire who is genuinely strong across all of them, at a salary a mid-market company can support, is rare.

What’s the alternative to a lengthy full-time search?

Many growth-stage companies bring in a fractional marketing director to provide senior strategic leadership immediately, while continuing a full-time search in parallel or deciding they don’t need a full-time role at all.